Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (2024)

Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (1)

We've been independently researching and testing products for over 120 years. If you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more about our review process.

  • Reviews
  • Best Value
  • How We Test
  • What to Look For
  • FAQs
  • Meet the Experts
  • You can help your pearly whites sparkle by upgrading your oral care routine with teeth whitening kits and electric toothbrushes. But one of the easiest and most affordable ways to tackle stubborn stains is using an effective whitening toothpaste.

    Whitening toothpastes are designed to remove surface stains from coffee, wine and similar substances. Don't worry if you see hydrogen peroxide on the ingredient list: It's a common, low-concentration whitening agent. These toothpastes may also contain mild abrasives that effectively remove stains without harming enamel, says cosmetic dentist Richard Lipari, D.D.S.

    Be aware, though, that some ingredients may cause sensitivity. To help, we consulted experts for their top recommendations. To find the best whitening toothpaste for your needs, our editors compiled this list of top picks, featuring recommendations from board-certified dentists and products tested by the Good Housekeeping Institute.

    1

    Best Overall

    Colgate Optic White Renewal Teeth Whitening Toothpaste

    Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (9)

    Pros
    • Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (10)High levels of hydrogen peroxide
    • Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (11)Effectively removes stains
    • Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (12)Affordable
    Cons
    • Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (13)Not ideal for sensitive teeth

    Noticeably brighten and whiten teeth while brushing with Colgate’s game-changing whitening toothpaste, a GH Beauty Award winner. The formula contains high levels of bleaching active hydrogen peroxide to brighten teeth one to two shades lighter and faster.

    After analyzing the brand's data, our experts in the GH Beauty Lab confirm that this formula can remove up to 10 years of yellow stains on teeth in only four weeks of twice-daily use. "It works!" one Walmart reviewer raved. "I drink a lot of coffee and tea, and I noticed that my teeth are so much whiter after using this toothpaste."

    Colgate Optic White contains gentle abrasives to scrub stains and polish teeth. It's the only American Dental Association-approved bleaching toothpaste that is formulated with fluoride for cavity prevention. It forms a protective layer on teeth, allowing the hydrogen peroxide to continue its whitening action beyond the time spent actively brushing.

    Ingredients: Hydrogen peroxide, hydrated silica, fluoride | Size: 3 oz.

    2

    Best Value

    Arm & Hammer Advance White

    Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (14)

    Pros
    • Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (15)Gentle yet effective
    • Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (16)Budget friendly
    Cons
    • Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (17)Not the best taste

    This formula harnesses the power of Arm & Hammer baking soda to naturally lift stains. Grace Yum, D.D.S., a board-certified pediatric dentist in Chicago, said dentists in her office who treated college kids and parents used this toothpaste to keep their teeth white after professional in-office bleaching.

    The brand claims it gently removes up to three times more plaque even in hard-to-brush places. Those who've ever tried baking soda as a teeth whitener know that it comes with a bit of a grimace, though: "Not the greatest-tasting, but that is a small sacrifice for healthy teeth and gums," said one shopper.

    Ingredients: Sodium Bicarbonate | Size: 6 oz

    3

    Best for Sensitive Teeth

    Crest Sensitive & Gum All Day Protection Anticavity Fluoride Toothpaste

    Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (18)

    Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (19)

    Pros
    • Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (20)ADA-approved formula
    • Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (21)Whitens and relieves sensitivity
    Cons
    • Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (22)May take longer to see visible results

    Catering to both sensitive teeth and gums, the Crest Sensitive & Gum All Day Protection Anticavity Fluoride toothpaste garners notoriety for its effective (yet gentle) stain-lifting powers. In fact, it's the only ADA-approved toothpaste that targets both sensitivity relief and whitening, an anomaly in whitening toothpaste.

    The formula goes by route of less aggressive surface stain removers like hydrated silica and stannous fluoride, a known favorable ingredient for sensitive teeth, according to Dr. Becker. This Crest formula offers a light minty-fresh taste that shoppers say tastes great. It also boasts a foamy formula sans grittiness. Most online reviewers reported noticeable whitening effects after about four weeks of use, which is longer than some other picks, but still effective.

    Ingredients: Stannous fluoride, hydrated silica | Size: 4.1 oz

    4

    Best for Gum Care

    Colgate Total Plaque Pro Release Whitening Toothpaste

    Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (23)

    Pros
    • Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (24)Effectively reduces plaque buildup
    • Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (25)Stannous fluoride helps curb sensitivity
    Cons
    • Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (26)Mint flavor can be strong

    No need to dread the teeth-scraping portion of your next dental cleaning. Switching to the Colgate toothpaste about three months before her dental visit, one of our Beauty Lab analysts heard praise from her own dentist for the significantly less plaque buildup on her teeth. "I am happy I found a toothpaste that can keep plaque under control and has whitening properties at the same time!" she said.

    This multi-tasking Colgate toothpaste helps fight cavities, whiten teeth and dissolve plaque, the latter of which may be thanks to its hydrated silica. In addition to whitening power, it also has gentle stannous fluoride that works to offset the sensitivity some people experience when using whitening toothpaste. Many shoppers enjoyed the refreshing feeling, but others found it a bit strong at first.

    Ingredients: Stannous fluoride, hydrated silica | Size: 3.4 oz

    Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

    5

    BEST FOR CAVITY PREVENTION

    Sensodyne Extra Whitening Toothpaste

    Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (27)

    Pros
    • Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (28)Non-irritating to teeth and gums
    • Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (29)Gentle whitening
    Cons
    • Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (30)Lots of air in tube, per reviews

    Those with sensitive teeth who want pearly whites without that harsh pang from sipping a cold beverage: Enter Sensodyne. Dr. Lipari recommends this extra whitening pick for his patients with sensitive teeth. Rather than focusing on brightening alone, it also uses a dose of stannous fluoride, which prevents sensitivity and hardens the tooth surface. The hydrated silica gently scrubs stains while potassium nitrate protects teeth against sensitivity. Its formula claims to decrease sensitivity after two weeks of regular use.

    One GH editor and her entire family use Sensodyne. "It's great if you already have sensitive teeth and gums but don't want to slack on the whitening. Amazon reviewers echoed that sentiment, writing: "If you have sensitive gums, please do yourself a favor and try this!"

    Ingredients: Potassium nitrate, hydrated silica, sodium fluoride | Size: 4 oz

    6

    Best Treatment

    Crest 3D White Brilliance 2-Step Kit

    Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (31)

    Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (32)

    Pros
    • Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (33)Contains sensitive teeth friendly stannous fluoride
    • Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (34)Can provide noticeable results within a week
    Cons
    • Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (35)Comes with a cooling sensation that some may not enjoy

    Get a professional-looking polish without the major markup. Lauren Becker, D.D.S., a general and cosmetic dentist in New York City, names the Crest HD two-step whitening system as her favorite over-the-counter whitening product that "gives patients noticeable results in under a week."

    Carving out less time than whitening strips, the two-minute application substitutes your normal brushing routine. The first step cleanser helps remove plaque and protects against sensitivity, while the second step contains whitening and brightening hydrogen peroxide, says Dr. Becker. Not to mention, unlike strips, these whiten the back of your teeth, too.

    Ingredients: Stannous fluoride, hydrated silica and hydrogen peroxide | Size: 4 oz and 2.3 oz

    Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

    7

    Most Gentle

    Twice Naturally Whitening Fluoride Toothpaste

    Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (36)

    Pros
    • Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (37)Great for sensitive teeth
    • Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (38)Claims to support gum health
    Cons
    • Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (39)More gel-like texture than paste

    No need to think twice when reaching for this whitening toothpaste. Jonathan B. Levine, D.M.D., a board-certified dentist and an associate professor at the NYU School of Dentistry, recommends the TWICE toothpaste line because it's "ingredients that are safe and help to remineralize the teeth" with its low abrasive index numbers. Translation: It's gentler on teeth.

    It's made with vitamins A, E and aloe vera that the brand claims to support gum health and freshen breath. Several online reviewers called it "refreshing" and agreed that it left breath smelling better. "This toothpaste is so good!" an online shopper raves. "I love the taste and the feel: Super clean and very fresh! My teeth are even a little whiter."

    Ingredients: Potassium nitrate and hydrated silica | Size: 3.4 oz

    8

    Best Natural

    Tom's of Maine Simply White Toothpaste

    Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (40)

    Pros
    • Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (41)Fluoride helps curb cavities
    • Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (42)Subtle mint flavor
    Cons
    • Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (43)Gel-like consistency

    Standing out among "natural" toothpaste brands by earning ADA approval, this pack-of-3 Tom's of Maine Simply White Toothpaste is a shining example of why the brand is well known in the natural products realm. For those who wish to steer clear of conventional toothpaste due to worries about ingredients, production methods or personal preferences, this selection is a suitable natural alternative that still whitens teeth.

    Similar to most whitening toothpaste options, it's formulated with hydrated silicas to effectively remove surface stains and fluoride for cavity prevention. One GH editor enjoyed its subtle minty freshness but found it offered more of a gel-like consistency than a traditional thick paste, as a matter of personal preference.

    Ingredients: Hydrated silica and fluoride | Size: 5.5 oz

    Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

    How we chose the best whitening toothpastes

    Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (44)

    The GH Institute's Beauty Lab rigorously tests all types of oral care, including water flossers, toothpaste, whitening strips and more. For past whitening product tests, scientists measure testers' tooth shades under standardized lighting before and after using a label-masked teeth whitening product as directed over a specified time period to gauge changes in tooth color.

    Testers also evaluate the products at home on factors such as ease of use, flavor, tooth sensitivity, cleaning efficacy (if applicable) and perceived whitening effects. Beauty Lab scientists then tally hundreds of data points to determine the top performers. While we haven't tested this category at large, the picks we included on this list were either approved by dentists, analyzed by our team of chemists or have ADA acceptance, meaning the organization supports that its efficacy and safety claims are backed up by clinical research.

    What to consider when shopping

    Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (45)

    ✔️ Active ingredients: The dentists we spoke with unanimously agreed that bleaching agents hydrogen peroxide or carbamide peroxide are key ingredients in whitening toothpaste. For peroxide ingredients, the maximum percentage is 10% for over-the-counter products, says Sharon Huang, D.D.S., M.I.C.O.I., a cosmetic dentist and founder of Les Belles NYC. Hydrated silica acts as a polishing agent to help remove stains. Baking soda also works to that effect while raising oral pH, adds Dr. Levine. Low pH levels mean high acidity, which can lead to demineralization, or the layer of protective enamel wearing down. This can make teeth more prone to cavities and other damage.

    ✔️ Sensitive-friendly formulas: Those with sensitive teeth may look for a formula with potassium nitrate, which is known to reduce sensitivity. Fluoride also helps prevent sensitivity and hardens the tooth's surface, according to a study. There are also products that don’t contain peroxide and instead are made with ingredients like aloe vera and coconut oil, which have natural whitening effects that pull stains from the teeth, according to Dr. Huang. "They're not as effective as peroxide, but are a good natural option that’s gentler on the teeth," she notes.

    Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

    How often to safely use whitening toothpaste

    Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (46)

    You can use whitening toothpaste a few times a week and then switch over to a toothpaste that has fluoride and/or potassium nitrate to help with sensitivity and demineralization, according to Dr. Levine. Check that the Relative Dentin Abrasion (RDA), or the abrasive index, is low, which means it gently removes stains off the surface of teeth. High RDA can strip away your enamel, and it doesn’t grow back, he says. Typically, you won't find these printed on a label. And while there are RDA index charts out there, it's best to check in with your dentist to be sure.

    Does whitening toothpaste make teeth more sensitive?

    Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (47)

    Everyone’s teeth are different. Talk to your dentist about what’s best for you. Dr. Lipari notes that at-home whitening products tend to have a lower concentration of whitening agents so it's less likely to cause sensitivity. However, whitening toothpastes contain abrasives that can strip the enamel over time, so it's best not to use long term. Also, if you’re finding your teeth to be more sensitive, look for formulas that have stannous fluoride or potassium nitrate.

    Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

    How long does it take to see results?

    Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (48)

    Typically within two to six weeks of use, though that all varies based on which toothpaste is used and how much staining there is, according to Dr. Becker.

    How to prevent teeth from getting stained

    Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (49)

    Technically, darker beverages like wine or coffee stain your teeth. While lessening that habit may be ideal, Dr. Becker simply advises to take proper care of your teeth to avoid erosion and staining. That means brushing twice daily, flossing frequently and regular dental checkups.

    Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

    Meet the experts

    Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (50)

    • Dr. Lauren Becker, D.D.S., is a general and cosmetic dentist in NYC. Dr. Lauren Becker received her Bachelor of Science degree in Cell and Molecular Biology from Binghamton University and she received a Doctorate of Dental Surgery from NYU College of Dentistry.
    • Dr. Jonathan Levine, D.M.D., is a board-certified dentist and an associate professor at NYU College of Dentistry who has practiced for more than 30 years.
    • Dr. Grace Yum, D.D.S., is a board-certified pediatric dentist in Chicago and the founder of Mommy Dentists in Business.
    • Dr. Richard Lipari, D.D.S., is a board-certified cosmetic dentist and a graduate of NYU College of Dentistry. He practices exclusively in Chappaqua, NY, focusing on cosmetic, restorative and implant dentistry.
    • Dr. Sharon Huang, D.D.S., M.I.C.O.I., is a cosmetic dentist and founder of Les Belles NYC in NYC. She received her Doctorate of Dental Surgery from Columbia University College of Dental Medicine.

    Why trust Good Housekeeping?

    Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (51)

    Jacqueline Saguin is a commerce editor at the GH Institute where she covers all things beauty. Through collaboration with the scientists and chemists at the GH Beauty Lab, Jacqueline has a finger on the pulse of top-tested makeup, skincare and health products in order to make informed picks for our readers. To round out this guide, she interviewed several board-certified dentists for their recommendations and expert advice.

    Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (52)

    Jacqueline Saguin

    Senior Commerce Editor

    Jacqueline (she/her) covers all things e-commerce in beauty, lifestyle and beyond for the Good Housekeeping Institute. Before joining GH in 2021, she was a style and beauty reviews fellow at Insider, testing viral trends, reviewing sustainable brands and more. She's a graduate of the University of Florida's School of Journalism, with a specialty in magazines and mass communication.

    Dentists Have Spoken — These Are the Best Whitening Toothpastes for Stained Teeth (2024)

    References

    Top Articles
    Latest Posts
    Recommended Articles
    Article information

    Author: Moshe Kshlerin

    Last Updated:

    Views: 6379

    Rating: 4.7 / 5 (57 voted)

    Reviews: 80% of readers found this page helpful

    Author information

    Name: Moshe Kshlerin

    Birthday: 1994-01-25

    Address: Suite 609 315 Lupita Unions, Ronnieburgh, MI 62697

    Phone: +2424755286529

    Job: District Education Designer

    Hobby: Yoga, Gunsmithing, Singing, 3D printing, Nordic skating, Soapmaking, Juggling

    Introduction: My name is Moshe Kshlerin, I am a gleaming, attractive, outstanding, pleasant, delightful, outstanding, famous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.